Near Field Notes

Videos

The notes, in motion

One video per topic, newest first. Point at a card for a silent preview.The card in the middle of the screen plays a silent preview. Open one to watch it whole.

41 videos, 41 with a note to read after.

3:08 · With sound

Fuses

What do a chip fuse, a polyfuse and an eFuse do when a USB port shorts?

Read Note 37

Transcript

The fuse on this USB port has tripped.

It's still passing 160 mA.

Here's why, how a chip fuse and an eFuse handle the same port, and which one goes where.

Take a 5 V USB port, rated for 0.5 A.

Three parts can protect it: a chip fuse, a polyfuse, and an eFuse, each the 0.5 A version.

I simulated each one with the same two faults.

A dead short at the end of a 1 m cable, and a device pulling 750 mA, half again what the port allows.

First, the polyfuse.

It's plastic packed with carbon, between two metal foils.

Cold, the carbon grains touch, and current flows.

At about 125 °C, the plastic melts and swells. The grains pull apart, and the resistance shoots up.

But it only stays tripped while it stays hot.

Holding this one there takes 0.8 W. At 5 V, that's 160 mA.

The colder the room, the more it passes: about 200 mA at 0 °C, 63 mA at 85 °C.

Now the dead short. With nothing in the way, the port would push 9 A into it.

The chip fuse melts in under a millisecond, and it's open for good.

The polyfuse takes 78 ms, and lets through 140 times the I²t.

The eFuse cuts it off in 0.6 µs.

Then it turns back on, and holds the current at its limit, up to 0.5 A.

It's built to shut down at 154 °C. 0.5 A into a short makes 2.4 W in it.

With eight thermal vias under it, that only gets it to 122 °C.

So it keeps passing up to 0.5 A into the short, until something tells it to stop.

Now the 750 mA device.

The eFuse lets it run for 8 ms, a delay I set with one capacitor. Then it opens, and stays off.

The polyfuse is between its hold and trip currents, so it might do either. A low-resistance one never trips. One at its 1 Ω limit trips in 14 s.

The chip fuse's curve doesn't even reach 750 mA. UL only asks that it opens within an hour.

So 0.5 A means three different things.

On the chip fuse, it's what it carries for 4 hours. Makers say run it at 75%.

On the polyfuse, it's what it holds at 23 °C. At 85 °C, it holds 0.29 A.

Its resistance can be as low as 0.15 Ω new, and up to 1 Ω an hour after a trip, or after soldering.

On the eFuse, it's a set point, ±15%.

And the chip fuse has an interrupt rating: 50 A at 63 V. Past that, it isn't rated to clear safely.

So, the chip fuse: tiny, cheap, and final. But it's one-shot, and slow near its rating.

The polyfuse: cheap, and it resets itself. But it's slow, heat lowers its rating, and it never fully opens.

The eFuse: fast and precise, and it can report a fault. But it costs more, and in a hard short it may need the processor to switch it off.

So which goes where?

On a USB host port, a polyfuse or an eFuse. The USB spec wants protection that resets without anyone touching it.

With an eFuse, wire its power-good pin to the processor, and let firmware switch the port off.

And put a chip fuse where a battery or a big supply could start a fire. When that opens, it should stay open.

On a polyfuse, tripped means 160 mA.