Near Field Notes

Note 46HistoryRev 1Watch the video · 3:00

FireWire and USB

Why did FireWire lose to USB?

FireWire was over 30 times faster than USB, and it became a standard 34 days earlier. It still lost. In January 1999 word got out that Apple wanted $1 for every FireWire port. That year Intel left FireWire out of its chipsets and went ahead with USB 2.0, which came out in 2000 at 480 megabits a second with no royalty. Two people who were there disagree on whether the fee was the cause.

FireWire against USB

Speed, date and fee

Over 30×FireWire’s top speed against USB 1.0’sTop speedFireWire400 Mb/sUSB 1.012 Mb/sA standard sinceFireWire12 Dec 1995USB 1.015 Jan 1996Patent feeFireWire$1 a port, reported 1999USB 2.0None34 daysFireWire became a standard that much earlierTop speedFireWire400 Mb/sUSB 1.012 Mb/sA standard sinceFireWire12 Dec 1995USB 1.015 Jan 1996Patent feeFireWire$1 a port, reported 1999USB 2.0NoneThe faster port lostUSB 2.0 passed its speed in 2000, with no royaltyTop speedFireWire400 Mb/sUSB 1.012 Mb/sA standard sinceFireWire12 Dec 1995USB 1.015 Jan 1996Patent feeFireWire$1 a port, reported 1999USB 2.0NoneOver 30×FireWire’s top speed against USB 1.0’sTop speedFireWire400 Mb/sUSB 1.012 Mb/sA standard sinceFireWire12 December 1995USB 1.015 January 1996Patent feeFireWire$1 a port, as reported in 1999USB 2.0None34 daysFireWire became a standard that much earlierTop speedFireWire400 Mb/sUSB 1.012 Mb/sA standard sinceFireWire12 December 1995USB 1.015 January 1996Patent feeFireWire$1 a port, as reported in 1999USB 2.0NoneThe faster port lostUSB 2.0 passed its speed in 2000, with no royaltyTop speedFireWire400 Mb/sUSB 1.012 Mb/sA standard sinceFireWire12 December 1995USB 1.015 January 1996Patent feeFireWire$1 a port, as reported in 1999USB 2.0NoneOver 30×FireWire’s top speed against USB 1.0’sTop speedFireWire400 Mb/sUSB 1.012 Mb/sA standard sinceFireWire12 December 1995USB 1.015 January 1996Patent feeFireWire$1 a port, as reported in 1999USB 2.0None34 daysFireWire became a standard that much earlierTop speedFireWire400 Mb/sUSB 1.012 Mb/sA standard sinceFireWire12 December 1995USB 1.015 January 1996Patent feeFireWire$1 a port, as reported in 1999USB 2.0NoneThe faster port lostUSB 2.0 passed its speed in 2000, with no royaltyTop speedFireWire400 Mb/sUSB 1.012 Mb/sA standard sinceFireWire12 December 1995USB 1.015 January 1996Patent feeFireWire$1 a port, as reported in 1999USB 2.0None
  • FireWire
  • USB

FireWire’s 400 is 393.2 megabits a second, 32.8 times USB 1.0’s 12. The fee is as The Register reported it on 15 January 1999.

Two ports, a month apart

December 1995 and January 1996

Both were meant to replace the pile of different ports on the back of a computer with one. FireWire is the common name for IEEE 1394, a fast bus for video and disks. The IEEE approved it on 12 December 1995.

USB 1.0 followed on 15 January 1996. Intel and six other companies wrote it for keyboards, mice and printers, at a top speed of 12 megabits a second.

The two plugs
Fig. 46FireWireIEEE 1394, 1995USB Type-AUSB 1.0, 1996Fig. 46FireWireIEEE 1394, 1995USB Type-AUSB 1.0, 1996Fig. 46FireWireIEEE 1394, 1995USB Type-AUSB 1.0, 1996

A six-pin FireWire plug and a USB Type-A plug. The pictures are not at one scale.

FireWire: one fast bus

1987 to 1995

Work on the bus began in 1987. Apple picked it up the next year, looking for a successor to its own desktop port, and named it FireWire in 1993. It became an IEEE standard at the end of 1995.

Who talks to whom
  • FireWire
  • USB
Fig. 46bFireWireDevice to deviceCamcorderRecorderNo computer between themUSBEverything through one hostComputerKeyboardMousePrinterFig. 46bFireWireDevice to deviceCamcorderRecorderNo computer between themUSBEverything through one hostComputerKeyboardMousePrinterFig. 46bFireWireDevice to deviceCamcorderRecorderNo computer between themUSBEverything through one hostComputerKeyboardMousePrinter

A drawing of how each bus is wired, not of any one product.

460

USB: built to be cheap

1994 to 1996

USB aimed lower on purpose. Its specification lists the goal as a “Low-cost solution that supports transfer rates up to 12Mb/s”. The six companies with Intel were Compaq, DEC, IBM, Microsoft, NEC and Northern Telecom.

How low was low-cost? The plug was meant to be a trapezoid, so you could see which way it went in. Making it a rectangle saved about a nickel a connector, so it became a rectangle. Intel’s USB lead told that story in 2025 and said he would make the same call again.

That nickel is why you flip a USB plug over, and then flip it back.

The plan and the plug
Fig. 46cThe planA trapezoidWhat shippedA rectangleSaved: about 5¢ a connectorFig. 46cThe plan: a trapezoidOne look shows which way is upWhat shipped: a rectangleBoth ways look right, and one fitsSaved: about 5¢ a connectorFig. 46cThe plan: a trapezoidOne look shows which way is upWhat shipped: a rectangleBoth ways look right, and one fitsSaved: about 5¢ a connector

The trapezoid is an illustration of the plan as it was described. No drawing of it is public. The rectangle is the Type-A plug, 12 by 4.5 mm.

1998: the iMac picks USB

Apple, 15 August 1998

For two years, hardly anyone used USB. About a million PCs had shipped with USB ports and nothing to plug into them, by the count of the man who ran Apple’s hardware then.

The iMac changed that. It went on sale on 15 August 1998 with two USB ports in place of Apple’s own older ports and the floppy drive. Apple lined up HP and Epson to make USB printers for it.

A PC’s ports in 1999
Fig. 46dParallelPS/2USBSerialSerialFig. 46dParallelPS/2Two USB portsSerialSerialFig. 46dParallelPS/2Two USB portsSerialSerial

The back of an Abit BP6 motherboard. USB sits among the ports it was written to replace.

The iMac’s ports
Fig. 46eDroppedADBSerial portsFloppy driveAddedUSBUSBLeft offFireWireFig. 46eDroppedADBSerial portsFloppy driveAddedUSBUSBLeft offFireWireFig. 46eDroppedADBSerial portsFloppy driveAddedUSBUSBLeft offFireWire

ADB was Apple’s own port for keyboards and mice.

462

1999: the $1 fee

January to May 1999

FireWire still had the high end. Then, on 15 January 1999, The Register reported: “Apple’s fee is said to be just $1 per FireWire port.”

This was an industry that had just reshaped a plug to save a nickel. A dollar is 20 nickels, and a computer can have more than one port.

A month later Apple backed down. On 18 February 1999 six companies agreed to pool their FireWire patents: Apple, Compaq, Matsushita, Philips, Sony and Toshiba. By May the fee was 25 cents a computer, however many ports it had.

The fee, in cents
  • FireWire
  • USB
  • The nickel
Fig. 46fSaved on each USB plugAbout 5¢Asked for each FireWire port$1, as reportedSet for each computer25¢USB 2.0’s royaltyNoneFig. 46fSaved on each USB plugby making it a rectangleAbout 5¢Asked for each FireWire port15 January 1999$1, as reportedSet for each computerby the patent pool, May 199925¢USB 2.0’s royalty27 April 2000NoneFig. 46fSaved on each USB plugby making it a rectangleAbout 5¢Asked for each FireWire port15 January 1999$1, as reportedSet for each computerby the patent pool, May 199925¢USB 2.0’s royalty27 April 2000None

The $1 bar is cut into nickels. The first amount is a saving, the next two are fees, and each is counted on a different thing: a plug, a port, a computer.

Intel’s answer: USB 2.0

February 1999 to April 2000

That same February, Intel announced that it was working on USB 2.0. One of its executives said of FireWire: “But that’s something of a niche, and it doesn’t make sense to integrate that into our chip-sets.” By August, Intel said FireWire would stay out of its chipsets.

Fifteen months, in order
  • FireWire
  • USB
Fig. 46g15 Jan 1999FireWireA fee of $1 a port is reported18 Feb 1999FireWireSix companies pool their patents25 Feb 1999USBIntel has announced USB 2.0. FireWire is“a niche”13 May 1999FireWireThe fee is set at 25¢ a computer31 Aug 1999USBIntel: FireWire stays out of its chipsets27 Apr 2000USBUSB 2.0 is released, at 480 Mb/sFig. 46g15 January 1999FireWireA fee of $1 a port is reported18 February 1999FireWireSix companies pool their patents25 February 1999USBIntel has announced USB 2.0. FireWire is “a niche”13 May 1999FireWireThe fee is set at 25¢ a computer31 August 1999USBIntel: FireWire stays out of its chipsets27 April 2000USBUSB 2.0 is released, at 480 Mb/sFig. 46g15 January 1999FireWireA fee of $1 a port is reported18 February 1999FireWireSix companies pool their patents25 February 1999USBIntel has announced USB 2.0. FireWire is “a niche”13 May 1999FireWireThe fee is set at 25¢ a computer31 August 1999USBIntel: FireWire stays out of its chipsets27 April 2000USBUSB 2.0 is released, at 480 Mb/s

Each date is the day of the report or the release. The rows are evenly spaced, not to scale in time.

464

Speed had been FireWire’s case against USB. After April 2000 the port that came free with every Intel chipset was also the faster one on paper.

Three top speeds
  • FireWire
  • USB
Fig. 46hUSB 1.1199812 Mb/sFireWire1995400 Mb/sUSB 2.02000480 Mb/sUSB 2.0: 40 times USB 1.1Fig. 46hUSB 1.1199812 Mb/sFireWire1995400 Mb/sUSB 2.02000480 Mb/sUSB 2.0 is 40 times USB 1.1, and a fifth faster than FireWireFig. 46hUSB 1.1199812 Mb/sFireWire1995400 Mb/sUSB 2.02000480 Mb/sUSB 2.0 is 40 times USB 1.1, and a fifth faster than FireWire

Megabits a second, from each specification. FireWire’s 400 is drawn at 393.2.

Why it lost: two accounts

Two oral histories

So why did FireWire lose? Two people who were there have told it to the Computer History Museum, and they tell it differently.

The two accounts

Fig. 46i

Apple’s hardware chiefIntel’s USB lead
Recorded20192025
What sank FireWireThe fee. Intel would not pay it, and pulled FireWire from its chips.PC makers did not trust FireWire. It tried to do too much, and it was always a year away.
On the fee“Basically that doomed FireWire.”Never mentions it
The turning pointIntel going ahead with USB 2.0Intel going ahead with USB 2.0

From the two oral histories. Each is one person’s memory, recorded twenty years or more after the events.

The record does not settle it. The fee was reported in January 1999, and Intel’s public turn came that February and August. Intel’s USB lead says his company had held USB 2.0 back for FireWire’s sake, and restarted it when FireWire stayed a year away.

Either way, the free port beat the fast one.

USB by committee

2000 to 2008

After that, USB grew by committee. The USB 2.0 specification credits 30 engineers from 7 companies. USB 3.0, released on 12 November 2008, credits 167 from 22.

Nobody from Apple is on either list.

Engineers credited
Fig. 46jUSB 2.0, 200030 engineers, 7 companiesUSB 3.0, 2008167 engineers, 22 companiesFig. 46jUSB 2.0, 200030 engineers, 7 companiesUSB 3.0, 2008167 engineers, 22 companiesFig. 46jUSB 2.0, 200030 engineers, 7 companiesUSB 3.0, 2008167 engineers, 22 companies

One dot for each name in the specification’s list of contributors.

The plugs multiplied too. Type-A and Type-B came with USB 1.0. Mini-B followed in 2000 and Micro-B in 2007. USB 3.0 added a wide Micro-B, the one on many portable hard drives.

Every one of them only goes in one way.

Five plugs, one scale
Fig. 46kType-A1996Type-B1996Mini-B2000Micro-B2007Micro-B 3.0200810 mmFig. 46kType-A1996Type-B1996Mini-B2000Micro-B2007Micro-B 3.0200810 mmFig. 46kType-A1996Type-B1996Mini-B2000Micro-B2007Micro-B 3.0200810 mm

Each plug’s face, drawn from its specification’s outline, with the year it was specified.

The names

As each specification prints them

A specification’s only credit is a list of names. These are the two lists, with each company as the list prints it and the companies in A to Z order. Roles such as chair or editor are left off. The USB 2.0 list has 40 entries because 10 of its 30 people sit in both of its working groups. Each is listed once here.

USB 2.0, April 2000. 30 engineers, 7 companies

Compaq Computer Corporation

  • Ken Stufflebeam
  • David Wooten

Hewlett-Packard Company

  • Matt Nieberger
  • Larry Taugher

Intel Corporation

  • John Garney
  • John Howard
  • Venkat Iyer
  • Steve McGowan
  • Jon Lueker
  • Mike Pennell
  • Todd West

Lucent Technologies Inc

  • Jim Clee
  • Jim Guziak
  • Dave Thompson
  • Par Parikh

Microsoft Corporation

  • John Fuller
  • Nathan Sherman
  • Mark Williams
  • Ed Giaimo

NEC Corporation

  • Nobuo Furuya
  • Toshimi Sakurai
  • Moto Sato
  • Katsuya Suzuki
  • Toshihiko Ohtani
  • Kugao Ouchi
  • Toshio Tasaki

Royal Philips Electronics

  • Geert Knapen
  • Zong Liang Wu
  • Gerrit den Besten
  • Marq Kole
USB 3.0, November 2008. 167 engineers, 22 companies

Acon

  • Glen Chandler
  • John Chen
  • Roger Hou
  • Charles Wang
  • Norman Wu
  • Steven Yang
  • George Yee

Contech Research

  • George Olear

Electronics Testing Center, Taiwan (ETC)

  • Sophia Liu

FCI

  • William Northey
  • Tom Sultzer

Foxconn

  • Garry Biddle
  • Kuan-Yu Chen
  • Jason Chou
  • Gustavo Duenas
  • Bob Hall
  • Jiayong He
  • Jim Koser
  • Joe Ortega
  • Ash Raheja
  • James Sabo
  • Pei Tsao
  • Kevin Walker
  • Tsuneki Watanabe
  • Chong Yi

Hewlett-Packard Company

  • Alan Berkema
  • Walter Fry
  • Anthony Hudson
  • David Roderick

Hirose Electric

  • Taro Hishinuma
  • Kaz Ichikawa
  • Ryozo Koyama
  • Karl Kwiat
  • Tadashi Sakaizawa
  • Shinya Tono
  • Eiji Wakatsuki

Intel Corporation

  • Kok Hong Chan
  • Huimin Chen
  • Bob Dunstan
  • Dan Froelich
  • Howard Heck
  • John Howard
  • Rahman Ismail
  • John Keys
  • Yun Ling
  • Andy Martwick
  • Steve McGowan
  • Ramin Neshati
  • Duane Quiet
  • Jeff Ravencraft
  • Brad Saunders
  • Joe Schaefer
  • Sarah Sharp
  • Micah Sheller
  • Gary Solomon
  • Karthi Vadivelu
  • Clint Walker
  • Jim Walsh

Japan Aviation Electronics Industry Ltd. (JAE)

  • Takashi Ehara
  • Ron Muir
  • Kazuhiro Saito

Microsoft Corporation

  • Randy Aull
  • Fred Bhesania
  • Martin Borve
  • Jim Bovee
  • Stephen Cooper
  • Lars Giusti
  • Robbie Harris
  • Allen Marshall
  • Kiran Muthabatulla
  • Tomas Perez-Rodriguez
  • Mukund Sankaranarayan
  • Nathan Sherman
  • Glen Slick
  • David Wooten
  • Rob Young

Mitsumi

  • Hitoshi Kawamura
  • Takashi Kawasaki
  • Atsushi Nishio
  • Yasuhiko Shinohara

Molex Inc.

  • Tom Lu
  • Edmund Poh
  • Scott Sommers
  • Jason Squire

NEC Corporation

  • Nobuo Furuya
  • Hiroshi Kariya
  • Masami Katagiri
  • Yuichi Mizoguchi
  • Kats Nakazawa
  • Nobuyuki Mizukoshi
  • Yutaka Noguchi
  • Hajime Nozaki
  • Kenji Oguma
  • Satoshi Ohtani
  • Takanori Saeki
  • Eiji Sakai
  • Hiro Sakamoto
  • Hajime Sakuma
  • Makoto Sato
  • Hock Seow
  • Yoshiyuki Tomoda
  • Satomi Yamauchi
  • Yoshiyuki Yamada
  • Susumu Yasuda

Nokia

  • Jan Fahllund
  • Richard Petrie
  • Panu Ylihaavisto

NTS/National Technical System

  • Dat Ba Nguyen

NXP Semiconductors, B.V.

  • Knud Holtvoeth
  • Martin Klein
  • Geert Knapen
  • Christian Paquet
  • Bart Vertenten

Seagate Technology LLC

  • Martin Furuhjelm
  • Julian Gorfajn
  • Marc Hildebrant
  • Tony Priborsky
  • Harold To

ST-NXP Wireless

  • Alan Chang
  • Wing Yan Chung
  • Socol Constantin
  • Linus Kerk
  • Chee Ee Lee
  • Veerappan Rajaram
  • Shaun Reemeyer
  • Dave Sroka
  • Chee-Yen TEE
  • Jerome Tjia
  • Hock Meng Yeo

Synopsys, Inc.

  • Robert Lefferts
  • Saleem Mohammad
  • Matthew Myers
  • Daniel Weinlader

Tektronix, Inc.

  • Mike Engbretson

Texas Instruments

  • Olivier Alavoine
  • David Arciniega
  • Richard Baker
  • Sujoy Chakravarty
  • T. Y. Chan
  • Romit Dasgupta
  • Alex Davidson
  • Eric Desmarchelier
  • Christophe Gautier
  • Dan Harmon
  • Will Harris
  • Richard Hubbard
  • Ivo Huber
  • Scott Kim
  • Grant Ley
  • Karl Muth
  • Lee Myers
  • Julie Nirchi
  • Wes Ray
  • Matthew Rowley
  • Bill Sherry
  • Mitsuru Shimada
  • James Skidmore
  • Yoram Solomon
  • Sue Vining
  • Jin-sheng Wang
  • Roy Wojciechowski

Tyco Electronics

  • Thomas Grzysiewicz
  • Masaaki Iwasaki
  • Kazukiyo Osada
  • Hiroshi Shirai
  • Scott Shuey
  • Masaru Ueno

The story in dates

1987 to 2008

FireWire and USB

  1. 1987Work begins on one fast bus
  2. 1988Apple picks it up
  3. 1993It is named FireWire
  4. 1995IEEE 1394 is approved on 12 December
  5. 1996USB 1.0 comes out on 15 January
  6. 1998The iMac goes on sale with two USB ports. USB 1.1 follows
  7. 1999The $1 fee is reported. Intel leaves FireWire out of its chipsets
  8. 2000USB 2.0, at 480 megabits a second, and the Mini-B plug
  9. 2007The Micro-B plug
  10. 2008USB 3.0, with a wide Micro-B of its own
466

Conditions

Speeds
FireWire’s 400 is the S400 rate of IEEE 1394, four times the 98.304 megabit base rate. USB 1.x full speed is 12 megabits a second and USB 2.0 high speed is 480. These are signaling rates on the wire, not measured file transfers.
Dates
IEEE 1394 by the IEEE Standards Board’s approval. USB releases by each specification’s own revision history or title page. The iMac by Apple’s press release of 19 August 1998.
The fee
As reported by The Register and Computergram in 1999. Each date is the day of the report.
The two accounts
Oral histories recorded by the Computer History Museum in 2019 and 2025. The trapezoid plug and the million PCs come from them too.
Counts
Different names in each specification’s list of contributors, counted from the lists themselves.
Plugs
Type-A and Type-B from USB 1.0, Mini-B from the USB 2.0 change notice of 20 October 2000, Micro-B from Micro-USB 1.01 of 4 April 2007, and the wide Micro-B from USB 3.0.

Sourced, not measured. Every number here comes from a public record, and nothing was simulated.

Limits

  • The $1 fee was reported by a news site as what Apple “is said to” charge. No Apple document giving the figure was found.
  • The two accounts are recollections. Neither can be checked against records from inside Apple or Intel.
  • Nobody has published a drawing of the trapezoid plug. Fig. 46c shows the idea, not a design.
  • “About a million PCs” is one person’s figure, given from memory.
  • A top speed on paper is not a transfer speed. This note does not compare how fast real FireWire and USB 2.0 devices were.
  • Same name is not always same person. The counts take each list as printed.

Files

  • data/contributors.csvEach contributor list, as printed
  • report/thread/thread.mdEvery number and date, with the document it came from
  • refs/photos/manifest.mdEach photograph, with its author and license

Sources

Like this note?

Rev 1 ·
  1. Rev 1First published

Each fix gets a line here, with the reader's name if they want credit.

Did it answer your question?

Want more on this?

Report a problem

What should the next note be? Ask for one