---
title: "Is a toroid the quietest inductor?"
topic: "Power inductors, part 2"
answer: "Almost. A 4.7 µH SMD toroid puts 0.094 mV on a trace 1 mm away, where an unshielded drum puts 7.5 mV, 80 times as much. Only a pot core with its gap in the center post puts less, 0.036 mV."
url: "https://nearfieldnotes.com/notes/inductor-types-2/"
site: "Near Field Notes"
author: "Michael Walker"
note: 36
family: "Power"
published: "2026-11-11"
revised: "2026-11-11"
revision: 1
video: "https://nearfieldnotes.com/videos/inductor-types-2/"
---

Note 36 · [Power](https://nearfieldnotes.com/families/power/) · Rev 1 · [Watch the video · 1:56](https://nearfieldnotes.com/videos/inductor-types-2/)

Power inductors, part 2

# Is a toroid the quietest inductor?

**Short answer:** Almost. A 4.7 µH SMD toroid puts 0.094 mV on a trace 1 mm away, where an unshielded drum puts 7.5 mV, 80 times as much. Only a pot core with its gap in the center post puts less, 0.036 mV.

A toroid’s wire wraps all the way around its ring, so the ring carries the field in a closed loop. What leaks is one turn’s worth.

The figure runs the same current ramp through both parts. The lines are the field, darker where it is stronger, and each trace glows with the voltage it picks up.

**Note 36’s opening figure: Unshielded drum, SMD toroid.** Both 4.7 µH, the same ramp through each

![Note 36’s opening figure: Unshielded drum, SMD toroid](https://nearfieldnotes.com/notes/inductor-types-2/fig-opening.png)

*What the figure shows:* Two 4.7 µH inductors on a board, each cut open by a quarter, with a trace running past each 1 mm away. On the left an unshielded drum: its field lines loop far out over the board, and the trace beside it picks up 7.5 mV. On the right an SMD toroid: its strong field lines run around inside its ring, the ones outside it are faint, and its trace picks up 0.094 mV, 80 times less.

*What the figure shows:* Unshielded drum, Sumida CD43NP-4R7MC: 7.5 mV on the trace. SMD toroid, Murata 83472C: 0.094 mV on the trace.

Both in the same 12 V to 3.3 V buck, each cut open by a quarter. Outside the toroid every line is the lightest shade, the weakest field drawn.

## Six more ways to build an inductor

*Cut open, at true size*

[Note 12](https://nearfieldnotes.com/notes/inductor-types/) compared five common ways to build a 4.7 µH power inductor.

These are six more. Four can take the place of those five in a buck: a toroid, a gapped ferrite pot core, a thin-film chip and a spiral printed in the board’s copper.

The other two do different jobs. A coupled inductor puts two windings on one core, and a ferrite bead filters noise.

**Fig. 36a: The six.**

![Fig. 36a: The six](https://nearfieldnotes.com/notes/inductor-types-2/fig-36a.png)

*What the figure shows:* Figure 36a: six inductors side by side at true size, all but the spiral cut open by a quarter. 1, a PCB spiral, 35 mm square, set behind the others. 2, a gapped ferrite pot core, TDK P 14x8, 14.3 mm across. 3, an SMD toroid, Murata 83472C, 7.8 by 5.2 mm. 4, a coupled inductor, Coilcraft LPD5030-472, 4.8 mm square. 5, a thin-film chip, TDK TFM252012ALMA4R7MTAA, 2.5 by 2.0 mm. 6, a ferrite bead, Würth 74279228111, 1.6 by 0.8 mm. Each is numbered under its part, and the first four are named there too.

One camera at one distance, so they compare at true size. Each is a real part’s outline with estimated insides, except the spiral, which is drawn for this page.

The noise test is the one from [Note 12](https://nearfieldnotes.com/notes/inductor-types/).

A 12 V to 3.3 V buck ramps the inductor’s current 1.85 A every µs while its top switch is on. A trace 10 mm long runs past, 1 mm from the part’s body, with its return in the ground plane 0.2 mm below.

The voltage on that trace is the [mutual inductance](https://nearfieldnotes.com/glossary/#g-mutual-inductance) M times the ramp. The coupled inductor and the bead do other jobs, so they sit out the test.

**Fig. 36b: The buck.**

![Fig. 36b: The buck](https://nearfieldnotes.com/notes/inductor-types-2/fig-36b.png)

*What the figure shows:* Figure 36b: a buck converter from 12 V to 3.3 V. Two switches take turns connecting a 4.7 µH inductor to 12 V or to ground, and the inductor feeds the 3.3 V output and its capacitor. A trace runs past the inductor 1 mm away, coupled to it by a mutual inductance M.

The trace stands for any signal that runs past. M is how much of the inductor’s field its loop catches, per amp.

## SMD toroid

*Murata 83472C*

A toroid’s wire passes through a ring and back around it, turn after turn, all the way round. Its field runs around inside the ring, which has no ends for it to leave by.

**Fig. 36c: SMD toroid, cut open.**

![Fig. 36c: SMD toroid, cut open](https://nearfieldnotes.com/notes/inductor-types-2/fig-36c.png)

*What the figure shows:* Figure 36c: the SMD toroid, Murata 83472C, 7.8 by 5.2 mm, cut open by a quarter on a board. Copper wire is wound all the way around its ring. Its strong field lines run around inside the ring. Fainter lines loop once through its hole and around it, and the trace 1 mm away picks up 0.094 mV.

Field lines darker where the field is stronger. The dark ones run inside the ring. The faint ones outside loop once through its hole.

SMD toroid

### Quiet, but not small

**Field marks.** A wound ring lying flat in a black molded carrier with two pads. Murata’s 83472C is 7.8 × 5.2 × 1.8 mm.

**Look-alike.** A common-mode choke, the same ring with two windings. Its load current cancels in the core, so that current’s field spreads into the air.

**Range.** 0.094 mV on the trace. The unshielded drum puts 80 times as much, the shielded drum 7 times. Its winding is 130 mΩ at most, three times the XAL4030’s 44 mΩ. Rated 1.10 A for a 25% drop or a 40 °C rise, $1.91.

**Habitat.** DC/DC converters, output chokes and EMI filters, as Bourns lists, and custom magnetics, since a standard ring takes any number of turns.

## The one turn that leaks

*Where the return wire runs*

Zhang and Wang split a toroid’s field in two. The turns, spread evenly around the ring, keep nearly all of theirs inside the core. But as it winds, the wire also advances once around the ring, and that one trip acts like a single turn the size of the toroid.

So one turn of the toroid leaks, where the unshielded drum leaks from all 17 of its turns.

A wire run back the other way can cancel that turn. Run back across the top, along the middle of the winding, it brings the trace down to 0.008 mV. Run around the outside of the ring, it doubles the voltage, to 0.20 mV.

The top return runs at the ring’s mean radius, 1.68 mm from the center, close to the 1.76 mm of the advancing turn as modeled. The outside return runs at 2.46 mm, beyond the ring.

**Fig. 36d: Two ways to run the return.**

![Fig. 36d: Two ways to run the return](https://nearfieldnotes.com/notes/inductor-types-2/fig-36d.png)

*What the figure shows:* Figure 36d: the same SMD toroid two more ways, each with a trace 1 mm away. With no return wire, as in Figure 36c, the trace picks up 0.094 mV. With a wire run back across the top of the ring, along the middle of the winding, 0.008 mV. With the wire run back around the outside of the ring, 0.20 mV.

The toroid of Fig. 36c with a return wire added, marked by each arrow. With none, the trace picks up 0.094 mV.

**The numbers**

*The same 4.7 µH toroid model, 1 A through it.*

| Return wire | M to the trace | On the trace |
|---|---|---|
| No return wire | 0.0507 nH | 0.094 mV |
| Back across the top, at the ring’s mean radius | 0.0044 nH | 0.008 mV |
| Back around the outside of the ring | 0.1069 nH | 0.20 mV |

## Gapped ferrite

*TDK P 14x8 pot core*

A gapped ferrite inductor winds its wire on a former between two halves of ferrite. A thin air gap between them holds most of the stored energy and sets the inductance.

**Fig. 36e: Pot core, cut open.**

![Fig. 36e: Pot core, cut open](https://nearfieldnotes.com/notes/inductor-types-2/fig-36e.png)

*What the figure shows:* Figure 36e: a gapped ferrite pot core, TDK P 14x8, 14.3 mm across and 8.5 mm tall, cut open by a quarter on a board. A round post rises in the middle of a ferrite cup, with the winding between post and wall, and a thin gap cuts across the post halfway up. The trace 1 mm away picks up 0.036 mV.

The arrow marks the gap, halfway up the center post. Hidden inside the winding and the cup, it barely reaches the trace.

Gapped ferrite

### Exact and quiet, with a hard knee

**Field marks.** A ferrite cup with a round post in its middle, the winding around the post, closed by a matching half. TDK’s P 14x8 is 14.3 mm across, 8.5 mm tall.

**Look-alike.** A shielded drum, also a round center in a ferrite wall. A pot core is two halves clamped over a wound former.

**Range.** 0.036 mV on the trace, the least in either note. Gapped sets are exact: TDK’s EP 13 is 100 nH per turn squared, ±3%. Coilcraft’s SER1360-472 holds within 1.4% to 6 A, then drops 30% by 12 A.

**Habitat.** Flyback transformers and chokes at 100 kHz to 1 MHz, where TDK places its low-loss ferrites, and filters needing an exact inductance.

## Where the gap sits

*In the post, or as a spacer*

The gap can go in two places. Cut into the center post, it sits inside the winding and the cup. Made by holding the two halves apart with a spacer, half of it ends up in the outer wall.

The outer wall faces the board. The same core with a spacer gap puts 0.85 mV on the trace, 24 times as much as with the gap in the post.

TI’s magnetics design notes warn of it: spacing the halves apart “propagates considerable stray flux outside the inductor”.

**Fig. 36f: Two ways to gap one core.**

![Fig. 36f: Two ways to gap one core](https://nearfieldnotes.com/notes/inductor-types-2/fig-36f.png)

*What the figure shows:* Figure 36f: the same pot core two ways, each with a trace 1 mm away. With the whole gap in the center post, the trace picks up 0.036 mV. With the core halves held apart by a spacer, so half the gap is in the post and half in the outer wall, it picks up 0.85 mV, 24 times as much.

Both scaled to 4.70 µH, each with a trace 1 mm away. The arrows mark the gap.

**The numbers**

*Ferrite µ 2300 unless stated. Each run’s M is scaled to 4.70 µH by M ∝ √L.*

| Gap | Model | M as run | M at 4.70 µH | On the trace |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Gap in the post | 4.99 µH | 0.0200 nH | 0.0194 nH | **0.036 mV** |
| Gap as a spacer | 4.79 µH | 0.4640 nH | 0.4595 nH | **0.85 mV** |
| Gap in the post, ferrite µ 1000 | 4.70 µH |  |  | 0.080 mV |
| Gap in the post, ferrite µ 500 | 4.75 µH |  |  | 0.15 mV |
| Gap as a spacer, ferrite µ 1000 | 4.70 µH |  |  | 0.87 mV |

## The gap heats the wire

*A second build, seven turns at 500 kHz*

This section uses a second build of the same P 14x8 pot core: M33 ferrite, permeability 750, with a 0.30 mm gap in the post. The noise test above used N48 with a 0.16 mm gap. Seven turns of 0.65 mm wire carry 1 A peak at 500 kHz.

The gap’s field bulges out into the winding beside it and drives eddy currents in the wire. TI’s notes say windings near a gap “have been known to melt”.

With the wire wound against the post, this build’s winding loses 61.9 times its DC loss. The turn beside the gap takes 72% of it.

The same core shape with its gap spread through the material, a permeability of 64 throughout, loses 5.6 times its DC loss.

**Fig. 36g: Loss inside the wire.**

![Fig. 36g: Loss inside the wire](https://nearfieldnotes.com/notes/inductor-types-2/fig-36g.png)

*What the figure shows:* Figure 36g: one side of a gapped pot core cut through its axis, with seven turns of wire beside the center post at 500 kHz, colored by the loss inside the copper on a log scale, three ways. With the wire touching the post, next to the M33 build's 0.30 mm gap, the loss crowds into the turn beside the gap and the winding loses 61.9 times its DC loss. With the wire three gap lengths away, 8.5 times. With no gap, the core's gap spread through its material, 5.6 times.

One side of the core, cut through its axis, with seven turns of 0.65 mm wire beside the post. The first two are the M33 build with its 0.30 mm gap, the third the same shape with the gap spread through the material. The blue lines are the field. The number under each is the winding’s loss over its DC loss.

Moving the wire out helps. Severns’ rule of thumb keeps it two to three gap lengths from the gap.

This build’s gap is 0.30 mm. On TDK’s coil former, 0.45 mm out, the loss falls to 18.2 times, and three gap lengths out, to 8.5 times. That is still more than with no gap, 5.6 times with the wire touching.

Magnetics notes that powder cores, whose gap is spread through the material, “are not susceptible to fringing losses”.

**Fig. 36h: Against the wire’s distance from the gap.**

![Fig. 36h: Against the wire’s distance from the gap](https://nearfieldnotes.com/notes/inductor-types-2/fig-36h.png)

*What the figure shows:* Figure 36h: the winding's loss at 500 kHz as a multiple of its DC loss, against how far the wire's inner edge sits from the post with its 0.30 mm gap. 61.9 at 0.05 mm, 18.2 at 0.45 mm, 8.5 at 0.9 mm, 5.3 at 1.5 mm. The same core shape with its gap spread through the material, the wire touching: 5.6.

The same seven turns, moved out from the post. The gray circle is the same core shape with its gap spread through the material.

**The numbers**

*Seven turns of 0.65 mm wire, 1 A peak in each, 500 kHz. The DC resistance rises as the wire moves out, since each turn gets longer.*

| Wire’s inner edge from the post | Gap | DC resistance | At 500 kHz | Ratio |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0.05 mm | 0.30 mm | 7.60 mΩ | 470.1 mΩ | **61.9** |
| 0.45 mm, on TDK’s coil former | 0.30 mm | 8.51 mΩ | 154.6 mΩ | **18.2** |
| 0.9 mm | 0.30 mm | 9.54 mΩ | 80.7 mΩ | **8.5** |
| 1.5 mm | 0.30 mm | 10.91 mΩ | 57.9 mΩ | **5.3** |
| 0.05 mm | None, µ 64 core | 7.60 mΩ | 42.8 mΩ | **5.6** |

## Coupled inductor

*Coilcraft LPD5030-472*

A coupled inductor winds two windings together on one core, so current in either one sets up field through both.

**Fig. 36i: Coupled inductor, cut open.**

![Fig. 36i: Coupled inductor, cut open](https://nearfieldnotes.com/notes/inductor-types-2/fig-36i.png)

*What the figure shows:* Figure 36i: the coupled inductor, Coilcraft LPD5030-472, 4.8 mm square and 2.9 mm tall, cut open by a quarter. Two windings lie side by side on one ferrite drum inside a square ferrite shield.

The two windings lie side by side on one drum, inside a square ferrite shield.

Coupled inductor

### Two windings that share a core

**Field marks.** Two windings on one ferrite drum inside a square shield, with four pads. Coilcraft’s LPD5030-472 is 4.8 × 4.8 × 2.9 mm, 4.7 µH per winding.

**Look-alike.** Two separate 4.7 µH inductors. In a SEPIC the coupled pair ripples about half as much, like two separate 9.4 µH parts.

**Range.** Its windings couple at k 0.99, a leakage of 0.11 µH. It is 10% down at 2.10 A, counting both windings’ current together. 111 mΩ at most per winding, $1.77.

**Habitat.** SEPIC, Ćuk and zeta converters, whose output can sit above or below their input, and small flybacks and bucks with a second output, which Coilcraft draws on the same sheet.

A SEPIC makes an output above or below its input with two inductors. Both see the same voltage at every instant, so one coupled part can do the job of the pair.

This one runs from 8 V to 11.6 V at about 1 A, switching at 500 kHz. With two separate 4.7 µH inductors, each one’s current ripples 2.0 A peak to peak. Wound on one core at k 0.90, each ripples 1.1 A, close to the 1.0 A of two separate 9.4 µH parts.

TI gives the rule: coupled, a SEPIC needs only half the inductance, because the mutual inductance splits the ripple equally between the windings.

**Fig. 36j: The SEPIC.**

![Fig. 36j: The SEPIC](https://nearfieldnotes.com/notes/inductor-types-2/fig-36j.png)

*What the figure shows:* Figure 36j: a SEPIC converter. From the 8 V input, inductor L1 runs to the switch node, which a switch takes to ground. A capacitor carries the switch node's swing to a second node, from which inductor L2 runs to ground and a diode feeds the 11.6 V output and its capacitor. L1 and L2 are the two windings of one coupled part, joined by a dashed line marked coupling k, with dots at the ends that swing together.

L1 and L2 are the two windings of one part. The dots mark the ends that swing together. The duty cycle is fixed at 0.61.

## Couple the windings yourself

*Separate, to k 0.999*

Set how tightly the two windings couple. The lines are each winding’s current over two switching cycles of the SEPIC.

Up to about 0.95 the ripple splits evenly. Tighter than that it moves into L1. At the LPD5030’s 0.99 the windings ripple 1.2 A and 0.85 A. TI advises 10 to 15% leakage for a SEPIC.

**Note 36’s explorer: Current in each winding.**

![Note 36’s explorer: Current in each winding](https://nearfieldnotes.com/notes/inductor-types-2/fig-explore.png)

*What the figure shows:* The current in each winding of the SEPIC over two switching cycles, for the chosen coupling. L1's current is drawn in orange and L2's in blue.

Each coupling is its own run, 4.7 µH per winding, ripple peak to peak. Two separate 9.4 µH inductors ripple 1.0 A each.

**The numbers**

*Peak to peak, 4.7 µH per winding unless stated.*

| Coupling | Ripple in L1 | Ripple in L2 |
|---|---|---|
| Separate | 2.0 A | 2.0 A |
| k = 0.90 | 1.1 A | 1.1 A |
| k = 0.95 | 1.0 A | 1.0 A |
| k = 0.98 | 1.1 A | 0.97 A |
| k = 0.99 | 1.2 A | 0.85 A |
| k = 0.995 | 1.3 A | 0.68 A |
| k = 0.999 | 1.5 A | 0.51 A |
| Two separate 9.4 µH | 1.0 A | 1.0 A |

## Thin-film chip

*TDK TFM252012ALMA4R7MTAA*

A thin-film chip forms its coil as a film of copper and buries it in metal powder bound in resin, in the same small box as a multilayer chip.

**Fig. 36k: Thin-film and multilayer, cut open.**

![Fig. 36k: Thin-film and multilayer, cut open](https://nearfieldnotes.com/notes/inductor-types-2/fig-36k.png)

*What the figure shows:* Figure 36k: two 4.7 µH chips of the same 2.5 by 2.0 mm size, cut open, each with a trace 1 mm away. The thin-film chip, TDK TFM252012ALMA4R7MTAA, a thin copper coil in metal powder, puts 1.0 mV on its trace. The multilayer chip, Murata LQM2HPN4R7MG0L, a printed coil in ferrite, puts 0.44 mV.

Both 4.7 µH in a 2.5 × 2.0 mm box, each with a trace 1 mm away. The traces glow by the voltage they pick up, faintly at these levels.

Thin-film chip

### Small, and it holds its inductance

**Field marks.** A dark chip with metal ends, the size and shape of a ceramic capacitor. TDK’s TFM252012ALMA4R7MTAA is 2.5 × 2.0 × 1.2 mm.

**Look-alike.** Murata’s multilayer LQM2HPN4R7MG0L, in the same 2520 size. Its coil is printed in silver and fired inside ferrite.

**Range.** 1.0 mV on the trace, 2.3 times the multilayer chip’s. 30% down at 2.1 A, against 0.18 A. 180 mΩ typical, rated 1.6 A for a 40 °C rise and 20 V at most, $0.57.

**Habitat.** Small, fast converters. TDK lists car cameras, radar and driver-assist units for this part, and phones, tablets and SSDs for its commercial range.

## Thin-film against multilayer

*From each datasheet*

Both are sold as 4.7 µH. As the current rises, the multilayer chip’s ferrite gives way almost at once. The thin-film chip’s metal powder holds on, which TDK’s patent credits to metal’s better behavior under DC.

The thin-film chip carries 12 times the current to the same 30% drop. In return it puts 2.3 times the voltage on the trace, and its winding is 180 mΩ against 110 mΩ typical.

**Fig. 36l: Inductance against current.**

![Fig. 36l: Inductance against current](https://nearfieldnotes.com/notes/inductor-types-2/fig-36l.png)

*What the figure shows:* Figure 36l: inductance against the steady current through each 4.7 µH chip, from its datasheet. The thin-film chip slopes down gradually and has lost 30% at 2.1 A. The multilayer chip falls steeply from the start and has lost 30% at 0.18 A.

Each dot marks 30% below the chip’s inductance with no current. Each curve is read from its datasheet’s chart.

**The numbers**

*Read from TDK’s chart, and from Murata’s at 20 °C as in Note 12. 30% down at 2.1 A and 0.18 A.*

| Current | Thin-film chip | Multilayer chip |
|---|---|---|
| 0 A | 4.72 µH | 4.25 µH |
| 0.05 A |  | 4.24 µH |
| 0.1 A |  | 3.73 µH |
| 0.2 A |  | 2.78 µH |
| 0.3 A |  | 2.18 µH |
| 0.4 A |  | 1.76 µH |
| 0.5 A | 4.60 µH | 1.46 µH |
| 0.6 A |  | 1.24 µH |
| 0.7 A |  | 1.07 µH |
| 0.8 A |  | 0.93 µH |
| 0.9 A |  | 0.83 µH |
| 1 A | 4.30 µH | 0.73 µH |
| 1.1 A |  | 0.66 µH |
| 1.5 A | 3.89 µH |  |
| 2 A | 3.41 µH |  |
| 2.5 A | 2.87 µH |  |
| 3 A | 2.18 µH |  |

## Ferrite bead

*Würth 74279228111*

A ferrite bead is a few turns of conductor inside a lossy ferrite. Above a certain frequency it acts as a resistor and turns noise into heat.

**Fig. 36m: Ferrite bead, cut open.**

![Fig. 36m: Ferrite bead, cut open](https://nearfieldnotes.com/notes/inductor-types-2/fig-36m.png)

*What the figure shows:* Figure 36m: the ferrite bead, Würth 74279228111, an 0603 chip 1.6 by 0.8 mm, cut open by a quarter: a few turns of printed conductor inside ferrite, with metal caps on its ends. Drawn far larger than the other parts.

An 0603 chip, drawn far larger than the other parts. The scale bar gives its size.

Ferrite bead

### A resistor for noise, until the load draws current

**Field marks.** A chip with metal ends, like a small multilayer inductor. Würth’s 74279228111 is an 0603, 1.6 × 0.8 × 0.8 mm.

**Look-alike.** A multilayer chip inductor. Above about 59 MHz this bead’s resistance is larger than its reactance, so it absorbs noise that an inductor would store.

**Range.** 105 Ω at 100 MHz with no current, sold as 110 Ω ±25%. With 1 A through it, 14.7 Ω, and 4.3 Ω at 4 A. Rated 4.1 A for a 40 °C rise, 14.5 mΩ typical, $0.31.

**Habitat.** Supply pins with noise in the tens to hundreds of MHz, run at about 20% of rated current, as Analog Devices advises.

## A bead under DC

*Impedance at 100 MHz*

A bead’s headline impedance is measured with no current through it. Run the load’s DC through it and its ferrite saturates.

This one has lost 86% of its impedance at 100 MHz by 1 A, a quarter of its rating. The 4.1 A rating is a heating limit.

With a ceramic capacitor after it, a bead can also ring. Analog Devices measured a bead and a 10 nF capacitor adding 10 dB at 2.4 MHz, the frequency they were there to filter.

**Fig. 36n: Impedance against current.**

![Fig. 36n: Impedance against current](https://nearfieldnotes.com/notes/inductor-types-2/fig-36n.png)

*What the figure shows:* Figure 36n: the bead's impedance at 100 MHz against the steady current through it, read from Würth's curves. 105 ohms at 0 A, 14.7 ohms at 1 A, 7.9 ohms at 2 A, 5.8 ohms at 3 A, 4.3 ohms at 4 A. Its rated current, 4.1 A, and a fifth of it are marked.

Read from Würth’s curves of impedance at each DC current.

**The numbers**

*Read by eye from Würth’s DC-bias curves, about ±10%.*

| Current | At 100 MHz | Lost |
|---|---|---|
| 0 A | 105 Ω |  |
| 1 A | 14.7 Ω | 86% |
| 2 A | 7.9 Ω | 92% |
| 3 A | 5.8 Ω | 94% |
| 4 A | 4.3 Ω | 96% |

## PCB spiral

*12 turns, 35 mm square*

A PCB spiral is a trace wound into a flat coil on one layer, its inner end brought out through a via. It has no core at all.

**Fig. 36o: PCB spiral and SMD toroid.**

![Fig. 36o: PCB spiral and SMD toroid](https://nearfieldnotes.com/notes/inductor-types-2/fig-36o.png)

*What the figure shows:* Figure 36o: a 12-turn square spiral of 0.6 mm trace, 35 mm on a side, printed on a board, and the SMD toroid in front of it at the same scale. Both are 4.7 µH, each with a trace 1 mm away. The spiral's trace picks up 1.8 mV, the toroid's 0.094 mV.

Both 4.7 µH, at the same scale, each with a trace 1 mm away. The traces glow by the voltage they pick up, the toroid’s too faintly to see.

PCB spiral

### Free to make, and the loudest in this note

**Field marks.** A square spiral of copper trace around an empty middle. This one is 12 turns of 0.6 mm trace with 0.3 mm gaps, 35 mm on a side.

**Look-alike.** Mohan’s formula, the usual estimate for a spiral, gives 4.76 µH. That holds with no copper under it. Over a solid plane 0.2 mm down, this spiral is 0.34 µH.

**Range.** 1.8 mV on the trace, 19 times the toroid’s. 0.96 Ω in 1 oz copper, and 1,225 mm² of board, about 3.8 nH per mm². With no core, nothing saturates.

**Habitat.** Converters switching at tens to hundreds of MHz, which need only tens of nH, and fields strong enough to saturate any core, as in particle detectors.

## The plane under a spiral

*Cut out, or solid*

A 4-layer board has a ground plane right under its top layer. With the plane cut away under it, the spiral is 4.70 µH. Over a solid plane 0.2 mm down, the same spiral is 0.34 µH, 93% less.

With no core, it also puts the most on the trace of any part in this note, 1.8 mV. Kamby and colleagues give stray field as their reason for printing a toroid on a board instead of a spiral.

**Fig. 36p: The plane under it.**

![Fig. 36p: The plane under it](https://nearfieldnotes.com/notes/inductor-types-2/fig-36p.png)

*What the figure shows:* Figure 36p: the spiral's layers drawn pulled apart, the spiral on top and the ground plane 0.2 mm below it. With a square cut out of the plane under the spiral it is 4.70 µH. Over a solid plane the same spiral is 0.34 µH.

The two layers drawn pulled apart, the spiral above and the plane below. The cutout is 36 mm square.

**The numbers**

*The plane is a perfect conductor at the ripple’s frequency in the model.*

| Spiral | Turns | Inductance |
|---|---|---|
| Plane cut out under it | 12.32 | **4.70 µH** |
| Solid plane 0.2 mm below | 12 | **0.34 µH** |
| Mohan’s formula, no plane | 12 | 4.76 µH |

## Noise on the trace

*Every 4.7 µH part in the test*

Beside Note 12’s five, the pot core with its gap in the post is the quietest, and the SMD toroid comes next, 80 times below the unshielded drum.

The same pot core with a spacer gap lands beside the molded and shielded parts. The spiral, with no core, puts more on the trace than any other part here except two drums.

**Fig. 36q: On a trace 1 mm away.**

![Fig. 36q: On a trace 1 mm away](https://nearfieldnotes.com/notes/inductor-types-2/fig-36q.png)

*What the figure shows:* Figure 36q: the voltage each 4.7 µH part puts on a trace 1 mm away in the same buck, one dot per part on a log scale, this note's parts filled and Note 12's hollow. Unshielded drum: 7.5 mV. Semi-shielded drum: 3.8 mV. PCB spiral: 1.8 mV. Thin-film chip: 1.0 mV. Pot core, spacer gap: 0.85 mV. Molded powder: 0.83 mV. Shielded drum: 0.67 mV. Multilayer chip: 0.44 mV. SMD toroid: 0.094 mV. Pot core, post gap: 0.036 mV.

While the top switch is on, from each part’s mutual inductance with the trace.

**The numbers**

*While the top switch is on, the current climbs 1.85 A every µs.*

| Build | Part | M to the trace | On the trace | From |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Unshielded drum | Sumida CD43NP-4R7MC | 4.0329 nH | **7.5 mV** | Note 12 |
| Semi-shielded drum | Bourns SRN4018BTA-4R7M | 2.0645 nH | **3.8 mV** | Note 12 |
| PCB spiral | 12 turns, 35 mm square | 0.9518 nH | **1.8 mV** | Note 36 |
| Thin-film chip | TDK TFM252012ALMA4R7MTAA | 0.5509 nH | **1.0 mV** | Note 36 |
| Pot core, spacer gap | TDK P 14x8 | 0.4595 nH | **0.85 mV** | Note 36 |
| Molded powder | Coilcraft XAL4030-472 | 0.4478 nH | **0.83 mV** | Note 12 |
| Shielded drum | Bourns SRR4018-4R7Y | 0.3634 nH | **0.67 mV** | Note 12 |
| Multilayer chip | Murata LQM2HPN4R7MG0L | 0.2381 nH | **0.44 mV** | Note 12 |
| SMD toroid | Murata 83472C | 0.0507 nH | **0.094 mV** | Note 36 |
| Pot core, post gap | TDK P 14x8 | 0.0194 nH | **0.036 mV** | Note 36 |

## Which build?

*Five questions*

The job decides first, then the switching frequency, the space and the inductance.

Key to six inductors

### Bead, coupled, spiral, thin-film, gapped ferrite or toroid?

1. 1a It filters a supply pin’s noise at tens to hundreds of MHz Ferrite bead
2. 1b It stores energy in a converter Go to 2
3. 2a The converter has two windings to feed, as a SEPIC does Coupled inductor
4. 2b It has one Go to 3
5. 3a It switches at tens of MHz and needs tens of nH PCB spiral
6. 3b It switches below a few MHz and needs microhenries Go to 4
7. 4a The board is tight and the current under about 2 A Thin-film chip
8. 4b There is room Go to 5
9. 5a The inductance must hold to a few percent Gapped ferrite, gap in the post
10. 5b 20% will do SMD toroid

Both ends of 5 are quiet: 0.036 mV on the trace with the gap in the post, 0.094 mV for the toroid. For amps in a small space, a molded powder part carries more current than this toroid in a smaller box.

#### Conditions

- **Parts:** Murata 83472C, TDK P 14x8 pot core B65541, Coilcraft LPD5030-472, TDK TFM252012ALMA4R7MTAA and Würth 74279228111, with outlines from their datasheets. The spiral is a 12-turn square of 0.6 mm trace and 0.3 mm gaps, 35 mm on a side.
- **Models:** Insides estimated. The toroid’s ring has a permeability of 60 and 21.4 turns. The pot core is N48 ferrite, permeability 2300, with a 0.16 mm gap. The thin-film chip’s metal powder has a permeability of 25. Each model’s turns set so it simulates 4.70 µH. The two pot core runs came to 4.99 and 4.79 µH and are scaled to 4.70 µH by M ∝ √L.
- **Toroid:** An evenly wound ring’s turns keep nearly all their field inside it, so only the winding’s one trip around the ring is in the field model, spread over the winding. Its turns’ inductance is calculated.
- **Board:** A ground plane 0.2 mm under the top copper, a perfect conductor at the ripple’s frequency. Under the spiral it has a 36 mm square cutout, except in the solid-plane run.
- **Trace:** 10 mm long, 1 mm from the body’s side, centered on the part, its return in the plane, as in Note 12
- **Buck:** 12 V to 3.3 V. While the top switch is on, the current climbs 1.85 A every µs.
- **Gap loss:** TDK P 14x8 in M33 ferrite, permeability 750, 100 nH per turn squared with a 0.30 mm gap in the post. Seven turns of 0.65 mm solid copper in one layer, each its own conductor with 1 A peak at 500 kHz. The no-gap core has a permeability of 64 throughout.
- **SEPIC:** 8 V in, a fixed duty cycle of 0.61, 500 kHz, a 12 Ω load, giving 11.6 V. A 12 mΩ switch, a Schottky diode, 10 µF of coupling and 44 µF of output capacitance, and 111 mΩ in each winding, the LPD5030-472’s most.
- **Curves:** Read by eye from each datasheet’s chart. The multilayer chip’s is Note 12’s, at 20 °C.
- **Solvers:** Elmer, 3D magnetostatics at 1 A, 13 runs for the trace test. Elmer, 2D axisymmetric at 500 kHz, 6 runs for the gap loss. ngspice, 9 runs for the SEPIC.
- **Ratio:** The toroid’s 80 times is the ratio of the two mutual inductances with the trace, 4.0329 nH for Note 12’s unshielded drum and 0.0507 nH for the toroid, 79.5 unrounded.
- **Checks:** Note 12’s unshielded drum and molded part, rerun here, give 7.454 mV and 0.827 mV against Note 12’s 7.465 mV and 0.829 mV. The gap-loss model at 100 Hz gives 0.9986 times the DC loss.
- **Renders:** Blender, from the same models

Simulated only. Nothing on this page has been measured on a board yet.

#### Limits

- The insides are estimates, and real ones will move each number.
- The toroid’s leads aren’t modeled. Its whole outside field is one turn’s worth, so its leads matter more than a drum’s.
- The pot core’s leak through its wire slots grows as the ferrite’s permeability falls. With the gap in the post it is 0.080 mV at 1000 and 0.15 mV at 500. With a spacer it is 0.87 mV at 1000, so the spacer is 11 times worse there, not 24.
- The materials are linear, so every field is the one at low current, before any core saturates.
- The gap loss is for one core and one layer of round wire.
- The bead’s and the chips’ curves are read by eye, about ±10%.
- Only the magnetic field is counted. The switch node’s voltage also reaches nearby traces through its electric field.

#### Files

- sim/parts.py Each model’s size, turns and permeability
- sim/geom.py The meshes, and how the toroid’s one turn is modeled
- sim/run.py The Elmer solve and each model’s inductance
- sim/noise.py The trace’s mutual inductance and voltage
- sim/lines.py The field lines, traced through the solved field
- sim/gaploss.py The pot core’s winding loss at 500 kHz, five ways
- sim/jmap.py The loss inside each wire
- sim/sepic.py The SEPIC, separate and coupled
- render/site.py The renders on this page, and the lines projected into them

#### Sources

- [Murata Power Solutions, 8300 series datasheet, the 83472C](https://pim.murata.com/asset/pim4/inductor/KMP_8300_PDF_INDUCTOR)
- [Zhang and Wang, near magnetic field emission from toroidal inductors, IEEE TPEL, 2020](https://peeprlgator.github.io/Shuo.Wang/publicationattachments/Analysis%20and%20Reduction%20of%20the%20Near%20Magnetic%20Field%20Emission%20from%20Toroidal%20Inductors.pdf)
- [Bourns, 2100LL series datasheet, toroid applications](https://www.bourns.com/docs/Product-Datasheets/2100LL_series.pdf)
- [Coilcraft, XAL4000 series datasheet](https://www.coilcraft.com/pdfs/xal4000.pdf)
- [Sumida, CD43 datasheet](https://products.sumida.com/products/pdf/CD43.pdf)
- [TDK, P 14 × 8 core and accessories, B65541](https://www.tdk-electronics.tdk.com/inf/80/db/fer/p_14_8.pdf)
- [TDK, EP 13 core and accessories](https://www.tdk-electronics.tdk.com/inf/80/db/fer/ep_13.pdf)
- [TDK, ferrites and accessories application notes](https://www.tdk-electronics.tdk.com/download/531536/133c4190b4d8aac6ea08cc21352bf2d8/pdf-applicationnotes.pdf)
- [Coilcraft, SER1360 series datasheet](https://www.coilcraft.com/pdfs/ser1360.pdf)
- [TI SLUP127, Unitrode magnetics design, the gap and its fringing field](https://www.ti.com/lit/pdf/slup127)
- [TI SNVA559C, cores and radiated noise](https://www.ti.com/document-viewer/lit/html/SNVA559C/transformer-inductor-cores-and-radiated-noise-t4589915-25)
- [Severns, additional losses in high frequency magnetics, APEC 1992](https://antennasbyn6lf.com/Rudy_tech_papers/APEC.1992.Additional%20Losses%20in%20HIgh%20Freuency%20Magnetics%20due%20to%20Non%20Ideal%20Field%20Distributions.pdf)
- [Magnetics, inductor cores: material and shape choices](https://p7f.vogel.de/companies/67/5b/675b0e99b4383/inductor-cores-material-and-shape-choices-en.pdf)
- [Coilcraft, LPD5030 series datasheet](https://www.coilcraft.com/pdfs/lpd5030.pdf)
- [TI SLYT309, designing DC/DC converters based on SEPIC topology](https://www.ti.com/lit/pdf/slyt309)
- [TI SNVAA43, a coupled inductor in a SEPIC, on leakage](https://www.ti.com/lit/pdf/snvaa43)
- TDK, TFM252012ALMA series datasheet, on TDK’s product site
- [TDK, TFM201610ALM series datasheet, archived](https://web.archive.org/web/20220226175632/https://product.tdk.com/system/files/dam/doc/product/inductor/inductor/smd/catalog/inductor_commercial_power_tfm201610alm_en.pdf)
- [TDK, TFM thin-film inductors overview, archived](https://web.archive.org/web/20251024042007/https://product.tdk.com/en/techlibrary/productoverview/inductor_tfm.html)
- [TDK, US 9,236,171, a metal powder core for a thin-film coil](https://patents.google.com/patent/US9236171B2/en)
- [Murata, LQM2HPN4R7MG0 data sheet](https://www.farnell.com/datasheets/4799566.pdf)
- Würth Elektronik, 74279228111 datasheet, WE-MPSB, on Würth’s product site
- [Analog Devices, ferrite beads demystified, reprinted by Power Systems Design](https://powersystemsdesign.com/ferrite-bead-demystified/22)
- [Burket, all ferrite beads are not created equal](https://emcfastpass.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/All-Ferrite-Beads-Are-Not-Created-Equal.pdf)
- [Mohan and others, simple accurate expressions for planar spiral inductances, 1999](https://web.stanford.edu/~boyd/papers/pdf/inductance_expressions.pdf)
- [Kamby and others, a printed circuit board integrated toroidal inductor, IECON 2012](https://orbit.dtu.dk/en/publications/printed-circuit-board-integrated-toroidal-radio-frequency-inducto/)
- [Pilawa-Podgurski and others, a VHF boost converter with air-core inductors, 2009](https://per.mit.edu/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/JPtpejun09p1654_VHF-Phi2-Boost.pdf)
- [Michelis and others, air-core inductors in a strong magnetic field, CERN](https://indico.cern.ch/event/11994/contributions/84503/attachments/63986/91934/Michelis_paper.pdf.pdf)
- [Elmer, the field solver](https://github.com/ElmerCSC/elmerfem)
- [ngspice, the circuit simulator](https://ngspice.sourceforge.io/)

What should the next note be? [Ask for one](https://nearfieldnotes.com/#ask-for-a-note)

---

Source: https://nearfieldnotes.com/notes/inductor-types-2/

Cite as: Michael Walker, “Power inductors, part 2”, Near Field Notes, Note 36, Rev 1, 11 Nov 2026. https://nearfieldnotes.com/notes/inductor-types-2/

Figures: free to reuse under CC BY 4.0 (https://nearfieldnotes.com/license/). Each one's image is linked under its name. Credit Michael Walker, Near Field Notes, and link the figure: this address plus #fig- and its number, like https://nearfieldnotes.com/notes/inductor-types-2/#fig-36a.
